Original Homies Gang Tapes Iraqi Cards Download Gang Articles Trace Tupac's Murder Some Gangs Get Sued

When information is omitted October 17, 2004 Victims of LAPD shootings sometimes win large legal settlements or jury verdicts against the city — even when the Police Commission has ruled that the officers acted properly. One reason: The commission often does not have all the facts. Here are 15 shootings the panel found "in policy" that later resulted in legal payments of $500,000 or more. In each case, the commission based its ruling on an investigative summary from the LAPD that omitted key information. Jan. 22, 1986 Victim: Javier Perez, 28, shot and killed in the parking lot of a Van Nuys condominium complex. Police account: Perez, suspected in a hit-and-run accident, swung a baseball bat at an off-duty officer. Plaintiff's account: The officer beat the unarmed Perez with the butt of his gun, then shot him repeatedly while the suspect was on his knees. Missing from LAPD summary: The angle at which bullets entered Perez's body contradicted the officer's account. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $630,000. * Nov. 6, 1987 Victim: Adelaido Altamirano, 41, a Los Angeles Coliseum groundskeeper, shot and paralyzed from the waist down. Police account: Altamirano pointed a gun at an off-duty officer. Plaintiff's account: Altamirano brandished a gun to fend off a mugger. The officer shot without warning. Missing from LAPD summary: The path of the bullet through Altamirano's body showed he was not pointing his gun at the officer when he was shot. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $5.5 million. * March 23, 1988 Victim: Jaime Cardona, 24, shot and paralyzed from the waist down outside a San Fernando Valley apartment building. Police account: Two officers tried to arrest Cardona for allegedly brandishing a gun. One officer shot Cardona when he tried to grab her partner's weapon. Plaintiff's account: Cardona was unarmed and never made a move for the officer's weapon. Missing from LAPD summary: Civilian witnesses said Cardona did not grab the officer's gun. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $675,000. * Jan. 13, 1993 Victim: Clarence Watson, 26, shot and paralyzed from the waist down after a traffic stop in South Los Angeles. Police account: Watson pointed a gun at the officer. Plaintiff's account: Watson was unarmed. Missing from LAPD summary: Gunshot wounds to Watson's right palm indicate he was not holding a gun. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $3.5 million. * April 25, 1993 Victim: Justice Hasan Netherly, 43, shot to death on the porch of his South Los Angeles home after he called 911 to report a disturbance. Police account: Netherly threatened an officer with a weapon that appeared to be an ax. It turned out to be a large stick. Plaintiff's account: Netherly called police after getting into an argument with his brother. By the time police arrived, his brother had left. The officer shot Netherly without cause. Missing from LAPD summary: A neighbor who witnessed the incident said Netherly did nothing to provoke the shooting. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $600,000. * June 27, 1993 Victim: Joseph Flores, 27, shot and wounded outside a South Los Angeles apartment building. Police account: Flores lunged at an officer summoned to quell a domestic dispute. The officer, mistakenly believing Flores had a knife, shot him. Flores was suicidal and deliberately instigated the shooting, hoping to be killed. Plaintiff's account: Flores was unarmed and did not lunge at the officer. Missing from LAPD summary: Flores told an investigator that he did not lunge but, rather, stumbled down stairs while trying to surrender to the officer. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $570,000. * Dec. 16, 1993 Victim: Sonji Taylor, 27, shot repeatedly, including seven times in the back, and killed after threatening her 3-year-old son with a knife. Police account: After police rescued her son, Taylor lunged at officers with a butcher knife. Plaintiff's account: Taylor did not lunge at officers. Missing from LAPD summary: A security guard said Taylor was not close enough to harm the officers when they opened fire. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $2.45 million. * Oct. 8, 1994 Victim: Larry Friedman, 24, shot and paralyzed from the chest down after officers responded to a disturbance at a group home in Northridge. Police account: Friedman lunged at police with a kitchen knife. Plaintiff's account: Friedman made no aggressive move toward police. Missing from LAPD summary: Two civilian witnesses said Friedman did not threaten the officer. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $3.25 million. * March 11, 1996 Victim: Eduardo Hurtado, 29, shot and killed after police pulled over a car to question occupants. Police account: Officers suspected the occupants were gang members in a stolen car. Hurtado tried to pull away while an officer was leaning into the vehicle. Plaintiff's account: Officers fired without provocation. Missing from LAPD summary: A passenger's account suggested that officers chased the car not because they suspected it was stolen, but because one of the occupants made an obscene gesture at them. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $900,000. * July 20, 1996 Victims: Juan Saldana, 19, killed, and Oscar Peralta, 19, injured, in a Mid-City apartment building. Police account: Saldana and Peralta pointed guns at police officers. Plaintiff's account: The two men were unarmed. The officers planted guns on them. Missing from LAPD summary: Witness statements that contradicted the officers' account. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $710,000. * April 17, 1997 Victim: Peter Williams, 40, shot in the stomach outside a Van Nuys tattoo parlor. Police account: Williams threatened a detective with a hammer. Plaintiff's account: Williams picked up the hammer to defend his boss, who was in a fistfight with a customer. Missing from LAPD summary: Witness accounts did not support the detective's claim that Williams threatened him. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $950,000. * June 18, 1997 Victim: Leonard Robinson, 51, shot and wounded during a narcotics raid. Police account: Robinson pointed a shotgun at an officer. Plaintiff's account: Robinson had dropped the shotgun and was trying to surrender. Missing from LAPD summary: Wounds to Robinson's right palm and index finger indicated that he had his hands in the air. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $2 million. * Jan. 1, 1999 Victim: Terry Taylor, 35, shot and killed in the backyard of his South Los Angeles home during a New Year's Eve celebration. Police account: Taylor pointed a shotgun at police. Plaintiff's account: Taylor was unarmed. Another man was holding the shotgun, which was unloaded and inoperable. Missing from LAPD summary: A relative of Taylor's told investigators that he — not Taylor — was holding the gun. Blood and ballistics evidence also contradicted the police account. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $2.6 million. * Feb. 8, 1999 Victim: Frank Harris, 14, shot at by police investigating alleged drug activity in a South Los Angeles home. Police account: Harris pointed a gun at an officer. Plaintiff's account: An officer masquerading as a gang member shot without cause and planted a gun to justify his actions. Missing from LAPD summary: The district attorney's office was investigating the officer for possible criminal conduct in the shooting. An earlier search of his locker found a fake gun, which investigators believed he intended to plant. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $1.7 million to Harris and co-plaintiffs. * June 11, 2002 Victim: Jason Mitchell, 33, shot to death after a traffic stop in South Los Angeles. Police account: Mitchell drove away with a police officer standing on the running board of his truck, then rammed parked cars in an attempt to harm the officer. Plaintiff's account: The officer shot Mitchell after the truck had come to a stop and he was no longer in danger. Mitchell had his hands raised in surrender. Missing from LAPD summary: An unexplained gunshot wound to Mitchell's hand. Commission ruling: In policy. Legal payout: $1.25 million. * SOURCE: LAPD, city attorney's office, court records News Topics | Home | Research | History | Blood Gangs | Crip Gangs | People| Life in a Gang | Gallery | Iraqi Cards | Memorial | Migration | Graffiti | Resume| Injunctions Homicides | Maps | California Prisons | Contact

Copyright © Streetgangs.com, All RIGHTS RESERVED. Disclaimer
All trademarks mentioned herein belong to their respective owners.